I’ve been watching for a ‘buy the rumor sell the news’ ‘risk off’ reversal, but it happened at best only momentarily after the Fed announcement, when the 10 year tsy note dipped to maybe 2.62 very briefly, stocks dipped, the dollar sort of held, gold was off a touch, etc. But now it looks like it’s ‘risk back on’ with a vengeance as both believers in QE and those who believe others believe in QE are piling on.
The fact remains that QE does nothing apart from alter the term structure of rates.
There are no ‘quantity’ effects, though from the following article and market reactions much of the world still believes there are substantial quantity effects.
And what we are seeing are the effects of ongoing portfolio shifting and trading based on the false notions about QE.
QE is not ‘money printing’ of any consequence. It just alters the duration of outstanding govt liabilities which alters the term structure of risk free rates.
QE removes some interest income from the economy which the Fed turns over to the Tsy. This works against ‘earnings’ in general.
QE alters the discount rates that price assets, helping valuations.
Japan has done enough QE to keep 10 year jgb’s below 1%, without triggering inflation or supporting aggregate demand in any meaningful way. Japan’s economy remains relatively flat, even with substantial net exports, which help domestic demand, a policy to which we are now aspiring.
QE does not increase commodity consumption or oil consumption.
QE does not provide liquidity for the rest of the world.
QE does cause a lot of portfolio shifting which one way or another is functionally ‘getting short the dollar’
This is much like what happened when panicked money paid up to move out of the euro, driving it briefly down to 118, if I recall correctly.
No telling how long this QE ride will last.
What’s reasonably certain is the Fed will do what it can to keep rates low until it looks like it’s meeting at least one of its dual mandates.
By Michael Heath
November 4 Bloomberg) — Asia-Pacific officials are preparing
for stronger currencies and asset-price inflation as they blamed
the U.S. Federal Reserve’s expanded monetary stimulus for
threatening to escalate an inflow of capital into the region.
Chinese central bank adviser Xia Bin said Fed quantitative
easing is “uncontrolled” money printing, and Japan’s Prime
Minister Naoto Kan cited the U.S. pursuing a “weak-dollar
policy.” The Hong Kong Monetary Authority warned the city’s
property prices could surge and Malaysia’s central bank chief
said nations are prepared to act jointly on capital flows.
“Extra liquidity due to quantitative easing will spill
into Asian markets,” said Patrick Bennett, a Hong Kong-based
strategist at Standard Bank Group Ltd. “It will put increased
pressure on all currencies to appreciate, the yuan in particular
has been appreciating at a slower rate than others.”
The International Monetary Fund last month urged Asia-
Pacific nations to withdraw policy stimulus to head off asset-
price pressures, as their world-leading economies draw capital
because of low interest rates in the U.S. and other advanced
countries. Today’s reactions of regional policy makers reflect
the international ramifications of the Fed’s decision yesterday
to inject $600 billion into the U.S. economy.